Is It Better To Mulch Or Bag Grass Clippings? What’s Best And Why

Are you a bagger or a mulcher when it comes to disposing of your grass clippings? There are arguments for both methods of course when it comes to maintaining a healthy lawn, but if you’re undecided, you may be wondering if it’s better to mulch or bag the waste from your lawnmower.

In general, if your lawn is healthy and doesn’t have a thick layer of thatch, mulching is the better option. It saves time and money plus it’s an eco-friendly way to provide valuable nutrients to the soil. However, if your lawn has many weeds or too much growth, bagging may be necessary. 

There are many other factors to consider of course and in this post, I’m going to explore if there is one method that’s better than the other and why. So if you’ve ever wondered what you should be doing with your grass clippings, then keep reading to find out!

What Do Mulching And Bagging Actually Mean?

Before we get into which method is better, let’s define what we mean by mulching and bagging. 

What Is Mulching?

Mulching is the process of leaving grass clippings on your lawn to provide organic matter and nutrients to the soil. 

This is best done with special mulching mowers with blades that chop the grass into small pieces, which then decompose quickly and return nutrients to the lawn. 

Mulching can save time and money by reducing the need for fertilizer and water, but it may not be suitable for lawns that already have excessive thatch buildup. 

What Is Bagging?

Bagging, on the other hand, involves collecting grass clippings as you mow and disposing of them in a waste bag or compost bin. This is often done to remove excess grass that could smother the lawn or to prevent the spread of weeds from seed heads in the clippings.

This method creates a neater, tidier appearance and prevents the accumulation of excessive grass clippings, but it also means you have to dispose of the waste properly which could be troublesome if you don’t have a compost bin or heap.

Which Is Best?

I think it’s fair to say that among lawn care experts, there is quite a lot of disagreement on the issue of mulching vs. bagging. 

On the one hand, many believe that mulching is a more sustainable and environmentally-friendly option, but on the other, some argue that it allows for the build-up of thatch and results in a messy-looking lawn.

Does Mulching Leave A Mess?

Mulching involves using a lawnmower equipped with a mulching blade that cuts the grass into smaller pieces and leaves them on the ground as the mower passes over. Some homeowners may be hesitant to use this method due to concerns about a potentially messy yard. 

Luckily for us though, by using the proper equipment, mulching can actually leave you with a tidy, healthy lawn without unsightly lumps of waste grass all over the place. 

Another common myth about mulching is that it contributes to the buildup of a dense layer of dead grass, roots, and stems that accumulates on top of the soil, usually referred to as lawn thatch. 

However, many experts now believe that mulching can actually help reduce this layer by providing more organic matter for beneficial microorganisms in the soil to feed on, which in turn will actually lead to less thatch.

That said, it’s still recommended that you dethatch a lawn with an excessive layer of thatch first as it will help the mulch reach the soil more quickly. 

Arguably, the biggest benefit of mulching is that it really helps to improve soil health. This in turn greatly reduces the need for artificial fertilizers which is great for wildlife and the environment

Are Grass Clippings Good Or Bad For Your Lawn?

As we now know, one of the most important factors to consider in the mulching vs. bagging debate is the nutrient content of grass clippings. Mulching your grass clippings provides a rich source of essential nutrients for plant growth; nitrogen, potassium, and phosphorus. 

In fact, it can provide up to 25% of the lawn’s fertilizer needs throughout the growing season!

Mulched grass blades also contain 85% water so this is a great way to keep your lawn hydrated, especially during the dryer months of summer, and will help the soil to retain the moisture from watering.

Overall, using a mulching lawnmower is an excellent way to naturally feed your lawn and is seen by many experts as one of the best things you can do for your grass.

However, there are some potential drawbacks of this method including the possibility of spreading weeds and a messy finish when not done properly. 

If the lawn is not mowed frequently enough or if the clippings are too long, they can smother the grass and prevent sunlight from reaching the lower blades, leading to poor growth patterns. 

Additionally, leaving clippings on the lawn can increase the likelihood of weed growth, especially if the clippings contain the seed heads of weeds.

Homeowners can avoid these issues by using a suitable mower and bagging when necessary.

Should I Bag My Grass Clippings If I Have Weeds?

If you have a weed problem on your lawn bagging grass clippings is a good way to help control it.

Bagging the clippings removes any weed seed heads that may have developed, preventing them from being left on the lawn to germinate. This can be especially important if the lawn has a history of weed problems.

However, it is important to dispose of bagged clippings properly to avoid spreading weed seeds elsewhere. Note that bagging also removes the beneficial nutrients of the clippings from the lawn and requires additional effort to dispose of the clippings properly.

Alternatives to bagging include using organic weed control methods such as manual weeding or using targeted chemical weed control methods to eliminate weeds.

When Not To Mulch Your Grass Clippings

While mulching may often be the best way to dispose of clippings, there are a few situations where it might not be your best option. 

Wet Grass

If you have no choice but to mow your grass when it’s wet, avoid mulching as the clippings will just clump together into a soggy mess. In fact, it’s best to avoid mowing wet grass at all even if you’re collecting up the waste.

If you do choose to mulch in this situation, be sure to mow over the clumps several times to help distribute them evenly.

Long Grass

Another time when it may be better to bag your clippings is if your lawn has gone un-mowed for over a week. In this case, the grass may be too long and the mulching mower will have a difficult job chopping this up into small enough pieces. 

This makes it difficult for them to break down properly and may need to be raked up after mowing in this case. 

Lots Of Weeds

As mentioned above, if your lawn is overrun with weeds like thistles, crabgrass, or dandelions, it’s a good idea to collect the clippings. Dispose of them responsibly and you can help prevent the spread of weed seeds and keep your lawn looking healthy. 

Chemically Treated Lawn

Finally, if you’ve been using chemical pesticides and synthetic fertilizers on your lawn for a while, it may be wiser to alternate mulching and bagging your clippings, at least to begin with. 

Harsh chemicals may reduce the number of microbes in your soil, making it more difficult for grass clippings to break down effectively.

By being mindful of these situations, you can make the best choice for your lawn and ensure that it stays healthy and green.

Should I Mulch My Lawn Before Winter?

Mulching before winter can be beneficial to lawn health by adding organic matter to the soil and allowing the clippings to decompose over winter. This can help improve soil structure, retain moisture, and reduce the need for synthetic fertilizers in the spring.

However, mulching before winter should only be done with a specialized mulching mower to reduce the likelihood of disease and pest problems over winter. 

Also, be careful of creating too much mulch when also chopping up leaves at the same time during the fall.

Additionally, be aware that heavy snow cover can suffocate the grass and prevent the clippings from decomposing properly so it may not be the best option in areas with harsh winters.

If you want to learn more about the last mow of the season, you can continue reading here

Final Words

By now you will know that mulching and bagging grass clippings both have their benefits and drawbacks. 

Mulching can improve lawn health and reduce waste but requires proper technique and equipment to avoid potential messiness. Leaving clippings on the lawn can also improve soil health, but may lead to shallow root growth and weed germination if not done properly. 

Bagging can control weed growth and prevent unsightly clumps of clippings on the lawn but it requires additional time and effort and can remove beneficial nutrients from the lawn.

Ultimately, the decision should be based on individual factors such as the lawn’s soil condition, grass type, and weed history, but do mulch if you can and your lawn will thank you for it.

Peter Toth

Hi! I'm Peter, the owner of BackyardGadget. Working around the house has always been a big part of my life. I've created this site to share my experience, and to help people choose the right tools for the job. Thank you for stopping by!

Recent Posts